Nuria Hernández Mora and Víctor Peñas Sánchez stress the need to protect aquatic ecosystems and advance towards sustainable water management
‘Water is a limited resource,' started Iker Mardaras Larrañaga, Director of the Sustainability Committee of the Gipuzkoa Delegation of the Basque-Navarre Institute of Architects (COAVN). ‘Its poor management, excessive pressure on reserves and the aquifers, or failure to maintain its quality can have detrimental consequences for society and the surrounding habitats.'
Mardaras also referred to the Global Water Bankruptcy report published by the United Nations University. It warns that consumption and pollution chronically exceed the world’s renewable resources. Mardaras ended by pointing out that this is the first of a series of talks about water, organised by the Institute of Architects.
Knowing the institutional background, the legislation, the challenges we are facing and the resources we have to address them are important.
Nuria Hernández Mora
PhD in Geography.
Nuria Hernández Mora works in water governance and drought risk management. She is currently a senior consultant at Fresh Thoughts Consulting.
Hernández started by recalling that water is a common heritage. ‘Access to water and sanitation is a human right recognised by the United Nations in 2010,' she pointed out. ‘The right to a healthy environment was also recognised in 2024.' And how we manage it has ramifications for other users and territories. ‘We therefore have a shared responsibility regarding its protection and management.' Hernández championed the role of politics in water management as the common heritage it is.
Water management in Spain is complex. If a river runs through different autonomous communities, it is managed by the river basin authorities, attached to the relevant ministry. If the river only runs through a single autonomous community, it is managed by that regional government. However, the case of the Basque Country is special. There are intracommunity river basins, that, however, are managed by the Eastern Cantabrian River Basin authority; nonetheless, there is an agreement in place for URA (Basque Water Agency) to hold the planning and management jurisdiction for some intracommunity river basins. On the other hand, some river basins of Álava belong to the Ebro River Basin District. Furthermore, local councils are in charge of urban water management.
There are many authorities; therefore, loyal cooperation and coordination between them and the users is fundamental to be able to manage the water efficiently and sustainably.
Hernández spoke about the great water variability in Spain. Rainfall is very variable and is being affected by climate change; it varies from territory to territory and over time, from the seasonal perspective. The use of water is also variable; it is atypical in Eastern Cantabria because 80% of the use is urban and the rest is practically earmarked for industry, while 80% of the water use in the rest of mainland Spain is for irrigation.
Hydroelectric production is also key; public investment in hydraulic infrastructures has been huge over the last 100 years or more. ‘Spain is what is known as a country with a mature water infrastructure,' Hernández explained. ‘There is little room left to carry on building. The benefits are undeniable, but we have overlooked the cost for a long time.'
There are several major management problems. The first is the loss of water quality. It has a particular impact on the aquatic ecosystems and even on the drinking water intake points. Much water in mainland Spain is polluted with nitrates, in other words, is not fit for human consumption. The second problem is that we are using more water than is available. Climate change is only aggravating this problem. For example, all model predicts lower precipitation in the foreseeable future.
And what solutions are being proposed? ‘We do not need to reinvent the wheel,' Hernández stressed. ‘In Europe, we have a fantastic European environmental legislative framework. What we need is the political will to enforce the law with ambition.' The Water Framework Directive shifts the focus from increasing supply to protecting the aquatic ecosystems. Water plans include measures in that regard, but little progress has been made. ‘The degradation has stopped, which is no mean feat, but improvements are slow,' said Hernández.
As regards climate change, there are European directives requiring a new approach: shifting from responding to the emergency to managing the risk. These risk zones need to be identified and assessed and, from there, we have to plan and act. The flood risk and drought special plans are one such example.
Addressing the Problem Locally
Victor Peñas Sánchez
PhD in Geography.
Victor Peñas Sánchez is a technician at the Basque Water Agency (URA) and is also an outreach specialist working on water management awareness-raising and educational initiatives.
Victor Peñas Sánchez ha hablado de la gestión del agua en Euskadi. “Tenemos un territorio muy pequeñito: 7.200 km2” dice. Además, incluye una divisoria de aguas cantábrico-mediterránea. “Los ríos son proveedores, además de agua, de felicidad”. Son las arterias fluviales que drenan, nutren y vivifican el territorio. Y hace falta romper con algunos hidromitos”. Uno de ellos es que el agua se “pierde” en el mar. Pero no es una pérdida. Es acabar el ciclo que empezará de nuevo.
Peñas spoke about water management in the Basque Country. ‘We have a tiny territory, 7,200 km2,' he explained. It also has a watershed between the Bay of Biscay and Mediterranean Sea. ‘Apart from water, rivers are a source of happiness. They are river systems that drain, drain, nourish, and breathe life into the territory. We also need to dispel certain water myths.' One is that the water is ‘lost’ in the sea. But it is not a loss. It is the end of a cycle that will begin again.
According to Peñas, the aquatic environment is not in poor healthy in the Basque Country. There are many contributing factors, from investments to the effort of the administrations and the general public.
The work in this regard includes achieving good water status, meeting demand and mitigating the undesired effects of floods and drought, as Hernández had explained.
Yet that was not always the case. Peñas showed how things had changed in a series of historical photographs. In the Basque Country, flooding is the natural phenomenon that causes the greatest risk and damage. His photos showed, for example, the historic flooding of Bilbao in August 1983. And pollution is the most important problem that degrades the health of the aquatic environment. ‘Great improvement has been made, but it is a latent problem,' Peñas stressed. The problem has not disappeared. The reasons include substances from the cosmetic and pharmaceutical industries; it is a pollutant for which today’s water treatment plants are not ready.
However, in general, the water status has improved, thanks to investment in sanitation and water treatment. There are still sporadic discharges, but are not the general norm as was the case decades ago.
In any event, it should be noted that Basque rivers have been clearly altered by human activity: dams, weirs and river channelization around which there has been excessive urban development. This has all had a direct impact on high flows and flooding. ‘If the rivers do not have riparian vegetation, the consequences are more damaging,' recalled Peñas.
A historical example is the change of course of the River Urumea in San Sebastián. Its change could be clearly seen in the photographs and graphics shown.
The dams and weirs have a direct impact on fish and other animals. They obstruct their movement and the transport of sediment and silt, and directly impact biodiversity. ‘Rivers transport life,' Peñas pointed out. Hindering that flow is an attack on river habitats.
Therefore, the approach of the water authorities is to eliminate obstacles, dams and weirs where they do not have hydraulic functionality.
Peñas also spoke about flood risk management. ‘High flows have been considered to be a fluvial pathology,’ he explained. ‘Yet high flows, to start with, are good for the river ecosystem. They are the driving force of the rivers; they are what keeps the river dynamics functioning.’ Therefore, it is the land use that is not compatible with river high flows.
‘River high flows cannot be stopped, for openers, because they benefit the river ecosystem,’ noted Peñas, ‘and, secondly, because it is impossible to prevent them, but we can manage them.'
He ended by stressing the need to educate the population at risk. ‘That is one of the handicaps that we are facing,' ended Peñas. ‘To get the public to know what to do when such a phenomenon occurs.'
